New Opera Forums launched

[emniss]

emniss last edited by

NodeBB

[jmwking]

jmwking last edited by

Can't be worse, right?

This is just a comment engine...

-jk

[amatczak]

amatczak Opera last edited by

NodeBB

Any particular reason to dislike?

[burnout426]

burnout426 Volunteer last edited by

We are basing on an entirely new, modern forums engine (NodeBB) which means: speed, cool new features and active development. We hope you'll like it!

Sounds awesome. Definitely like the sound of "active development".

[emniss]

emniss last edited by

NodeBB

Any particular reason to dislike?

Yes, it's confusing and chaotic by default and it uses ugly webfonts. Hope you got a real good template to resolve this

[amatczak]

amatczak Opera last edited by

Yes, it's confusing and chaotic by default and it uses ugly webfonts. Hope you got a real good template to resolve this

Thanks for sharing your opinion!
We'll be more than happy to hear your (and everyone in the community) comments about our particular take on NodeBB when we launch. We can promise that we will take all feedback seriously and prioritize future development of Forums according to your voices.

[A Former User]

A Former User last edited by

The forum still uses Markdown, but has buttons for formatting so that you don't have to read the Markdown guide first. Anything that can't be done in markdown (for example, underlining) won't work in the new forum.

That's good news!
Having to manually type code into your posts to get quite normal and common formatting options has always seemed to be a nonsense to me.
Very odd that Markdown can't do underlining, I would have thought that was a pretty basic formatting option.

[leocg]

leocg Moderator Volunteer last edited by

it's confusing and chaotic by default

Hmm, how? It doesn't look confusing to me. On the contrary.

[sgunhouse]

sgunhouse Moderator Volunteer last edited by

Confusing parts to me are the multiple levels of subforums (as in Opera for Devices > Android > Opera Mini) and the matter of threading - though that latter applies to email as well. Personally I like replies in chronological order, while others prefer that replies to comments appear near the comment they are in reply to. But personal preference is just that... I haven't looked, but there is probably a setting for that.

[leocg]

leocg Moderator Volunteer last edited by

Confusing parts to me are the multiple levels of subforums (as in Opera for Devices > Android > Opera Mini)

Interesting, for me it makes the forum looks more organized.

Personally I like replies in chronological order, while others prefer that replies to comments appear near the comment they are in reply to

For me it's enough to have a way to know to what the person is replying to once it's not always exactly obvious.

[sgunhouse]

sgunhouse Moderator Volunteer last edited by

The other thing: you can post in a forum even though it has subforums. I could post into Opera for Mobile directly, or into the Android subforum. Kind of like a directory on a disk - it can contain both files (threads) and folders (subforums).

[amatczak]

amatczak Opera last edited by

Actually you could post there only because you're a Moderator which has some implicit privileges

Regular users will be able only to post in specific subforums (with the exception of "Opera for computers" where we will allow to post without going into specific Windows/Linux/Mac subforum).

But the point I want to make is that the new Forums will allow us to continue to adapt to community needs - something were not able to do here - so if a particular solution does not work we might be able to change it.

[rodrigowbs]

rodrigowbs last edited by

nice :3

[leocg]

leocg Moderator Volunteer last edited by

But the point I want to make is that the new Forums will allow us to continue to adapt to community needs - something were not able to do here - so if a particular solution does not work we might be able to change it.

This is an important point.

[burnout426]

burnout426 Volunteer last edited by

Checked out a demo of NodeBB and realized I've already been using it when on https://forum.vivaldi.net.

It's pretty cool in general, but still haven't gotten used to a reply showing in two places (nested under the comment you're replying to and then as a regular comment in comment order).

Also, we've had to turn off pagination in settings because of this bug:

https://forum.vivaldi.net/topic/18916/when-pagination-is-checked-in-settings-stuck-in-the-first-page-of-this-forum/5
https://forum.vivaldi.net/topic/15821/possible-bug-in-forum-software-scroll-to-top-of-next-page

Not sure if it's something specific with NodeBB or just something the forum devs messed up though. It's kind of nice with pagination turned off anyway as posts lazy load.

Also, links in notification emails just take you to the post and not the specific comment.
https://forum.vivaldi.net/topic/13478/forum-email-notifications-link-doesn-t-point-to-reply

It used to work though, so I'm thinking that might not be on NodeBB's end. Hopefully. It's something I'll be testing right away.

[amatczak]

amatczak Opera last edited by

Also, links in notification emails just take you to the post and not the specific comment.
https://forum.vivaldi.net/topic/13478/forum-email-notifications-link-doesn-t-point-to-reply
It used to work though, so I'm thinking that might not be on NodeBB's end. Hopefully.

A quick scan of a notification email I got from our beta version of Opera Forums indeed confirm that the link points just to the discussion (reads "Click here to read the full topic") not the comment. Shame.

...but. When I click the link the Forums offers me a "click here to jump to last read post" popup. So it's kinda okay.

[burnout426]

burnout426 Volunteer last edited by

A quick scan of a notification email I got from our beta version of Opera Forums indeed confirm that the link points just to the discussion (reads "Click here to read the full topic") not the comment. Shame.

Thanks for the heads up.

[zalex108]

zalex108 last edited by

• Capitalize nicknames.
• Generic FAQ or Individual FAQ / (Common fixes) for each OS.
• User signature.

---

Windows 10 (x64) | Anniversary Update
Opera Stable · Beta · Developer

Test profile | Back up Linux · Mac · Win

"You cannot know the meaning of your life until you are connected to the power that created you". · Shri Mataji Nirmala Devi

[leocg]

leocg Moderator Volunteer last edited by

Generic FAQ or Individual FAQ / (Common fixes) for each OS.

I guess it can be handle, probably in the same way it is currently.

User signature.

There is an option for it in user's profile.

[zalex108]

zalex108 last edited by

Generic FAQ or Individual FAQ / (Common fixes) for each OS.

I guess it can be handle, probably in the same way it is currently.

Sorry..., but

There is no FAQ on Linux forums, nor on Mac's.
There is no reference to Windows FAQ into *Nix / Mac forums for shared fixes.
There is no reference into Windows FAQ for OS shared fixes and the title is quite clearly:

Frequently Asked Questions (Opera for Windows)

Even, *Nix and Mac Announcements has formating problems.

There is a lack on Help organization and for the most repeated questions.

User signature.

There is an option for it in user's profile.

After looking at Profile's options, can not find any option to add a signature.

---

Windows 10 (x64) | Anniversary Update
Opera Stable · Beta · Developer

Test profile | Back up Linux · Mac · Win

"You cannot know the meaning of your life until you are connected to the power that created you". · Shri Mataji Nirmala Devi