New commenting mechanism on Opera blogs
-
frenzie last edited by
Here we go, yesterday was an anomaly. These new forum-based comments here aren't as good as My Opera used to be (e.g., they require JS) but at least they work.
-
amatczak Opera last edited by
@andrew84
Hi, I have just updated Edit Profile page to include a short explanation and a link to the place where you can change email/password:
Thanks for reporting that and hope this helps.
-
amatczak Opera last edited by
Also, to make the Blogs <-> Forums jumping a little less frustrating, we have added a permalink to each comment. To open Forums now you can click on the post relative timestamp that's next to the username (e.g.
15 minutes ago). This will take you to the exact same post on forums.opera.com
-
andrew84 last edited by
@amatczak: Thank you for these changes, I also noticed that comments text size looks a way better now in the blog.
*Maybe forum's comment should also have some 'view in blog' option to jump.
And maybe there should be some more informative thing in the blog. Some clickable icon (small arrow for example) next to timestamp with 'view on forum' tooltip, or an extra 'View forum' button at the comment's bottom next to 'Reply' and 'Quote' buttons.
It's hard to guess without an additional info that I can click the timestamp to visit forum. -
-
-
-
-
amatczak Opera last edited by
Forums are tightly integrated with your Opera account. Therefore the username/email/password is always taken from your Opera account and cannot be changed directly on Forums. Due to technical reasons once you choose the username when creating your Opera account, this username cannot be changed. If you really want, you can always create a new Opera account using different username.
-
-
A Former User last edited by
This comment system is horrendous. Disqus was at least an omnipresent/everywhere type of commenting system where i could partake in discussions straight from the Disqus app on Windows.
This is a step backwards. There is no uniformity, there is no tree view on the actual blog and seemingly no upvotes/downvotes capabilities unless I go to the forums. Forcing users yet again Opera?
This switch in my estimation was a very very unintelligent move... yet again same people made Opera into the UI freakfest it is now so not very surprising.
-
A Former User last edited by
@artexjay said:
This comment system is horrendous. Disqus was at least an omnipresent/everywhere type of commenting system where i could partake in discussions straight from the Disqus app on Windows.
This is a step backwards. There is no uniformity, there is no tree view on the actual blog and seemingly no upvotes/downvotes capabilities unless I go to the forums. Forcing users yet again Opera?
This switch in my estimation was a very very unintelligent move... yet again same people made Opera into the UI freakfest it is now so not very surprising.
In addition to that there is no way from what i can see to edit a post again unless i head to the forums. As well as I've noticed that this comment system does not support adding images natively thus relying on 3rd party image sharing sites like imgur. On top of that there is the stupidest cap that unless you reach a certain reputation rank you cannot, comment often or even downvote/upvote?
I know Opera is obsessive with restricting it's users similar to how China likes censoring but come on. Your browser is restrictive and your forums too?
-
A Former User last edited by A Former User
@amatczak,
a jump blog-forum works. Back (here, used: firefox 60.9esr) not.
If, then it would make sense in both directions. -
A Former User last edited by A Former User
@artexjay said in New commenting mechanism on Opera blogs:
This comment system is horrendous. (...)
Yes! at least in the currently available form.
-
A Former User last edited by
since editing option has expired, another post:
Just logged in via account, then the option appears that you can participate in forum. If you click on it, you are in the forum - not (!) logged in. And you have to log in again or rather confirm your login with 4-5 clicks. Not very user-friendly and very impractical. -
-
amatczak Opera last edited by
Restricting edits to 30 minutes is a practical solution to prevent spam. There is a common pattern where a spammer makes a reasonable and seemingly on-point comment that obviously gets approved by moderation. Few days/weeks later he edits it to include a spammy link in hope it will fly under the radar. That's something I've actually seen being done in our Disqus-based comments, BTW.
Same reason is behind first-post-needs-approval and cannot post more often than X minutes at first.
And yes, you can upload images directly here. You don't need to use any third party service.
-
-
A Former User last edited by
@amatczak: I'm sorry, could you just say a few words, why did you give up the Disqus commenting system?
-
A Former User last edited by A Former User
@amatczak said in New commenting mechanism on Opera blogs:
@aphaltgrau What would be the reason (...)
not to dodge it. What is already stated in last post applies: a "jump-function" only makes sense if it is functional in both directions. Reasons don't matter at all!
_
ps: thanks for the editing period, wasn't known.
