Very long extension moderation process

[kurtq]

kurtq last edited by

Hello! Today version 1.7.7.2 was checked and rejected, all corrections according to your recommendations were made in the updated version 1.7.7.3. Please check 1.7.7.3, thanks

[tnowak]

tnowak Opera @kurtq last edited by

@kurtq : That's why the old version was rejected
And the review of the newest version is in progress.

[A Former User]

A Former User @tnowak last edited by

@tnowak
"There must be no unused files." - It seems there are no unused files.
"Well-known third-party libraries must be in a genuine and in an unchanged form. They should be acquired from the vendor’s official website or a CDN." - we use two libraries - jquery and D3js. They in a genuine and in an unchanged form. And they acquired from the official website.

[A Former User]

A Former User last edited by

Hey guys, we submitted our add-on on the 8th of Oct, 2018. Is there a way to speed up the moderation process?

[oktools]

oktools last edited by

Please post the extension. Made all the corrections indicated by the moderators.

package/21805
OkTools - v4.3 was submitted. Awaiting moderation.
oktools; Aug 22, 2019 12:35:01 PM UTC

[tnowak]

tnowak Opera @oktools last edited by

@oktools : We asked you to update links in the description to use HTTPS.

[tnowak]

tnowak Opera @Guest last edited by

@signalhire : Your extension contains obfuscated or minified scripts.
Please take a look at https://dev.opera.com/extensions/acceptance-criteria/

[phaistonian]

phaistonian last edited by

@tnowak Could you please take a look at package/233927 ?

Been trying to get this online for almost a year now

ps: Implemented what you suggested a while back.

[oktools]

oktools @tnowak last edited by

@tnowak Replaced absolutely all links from http to https in the extension and on the addons.opera.com page.

[tnowak]

tnowak Opera @oktools last edited by

@oktools : Thanks!

[A Former User]

A Former User @tnowak last edited by

@tnowak could you answer my question?
@commaticus said in Very long extension moderation process:

@tnowak
"There must be no unused files." - It seems there are no unused files.
"Well-known third-party libraries must be in a genuine and in an unchanged form. They should be acquired from the vendor’s official website or a CDN." - we use two libraries - jquery and D3js. They in a genuine and in an unchanged form. And they acquired from the official website.

[burnout426]

burnout426 Volunteer @tnowak last edited by

@tnowak said in Very long extension moderation process:

"Well-known third-party libraries must be in a genuine and in an unchanged form. They should be acquired from the vendor’s official website or a CDN."

How is the check done? SHA-256 hash comparison between the included file and the file for the latest version of the library?

Was just wondering how @commaticus could check before-hand just to make sure the system will be happy.

[tnowak]

tnowak Opera @Guest last edited by

@commaticus

1. Unused files in the last package you submitted:

    → find -type f -size 0
    ./site/removelisting.js
    ./noconcat/1_sth/obj.js
    ./all/script.js
   

2. Could you please provide links to these files on the official websites? I can only find ones with a comment containing the version number on the first line.

@burnout426
Libraries need to be byte for byte exact copies, so SHA-256 hash comparison can be used to check that.

[A Former User]

A Former User @tnowak last edited by

@tnowak sorry

1. Done
2. https://cdnjs.cloudflare.com/ajax/libs/d3/4.2.3/d3.min.js
   https://code.jquery.com/jquery-2.2.4.min.js

[oinkandstuff]

oinkandstuff last edited by

In my opinion, why is Opera is making live Debug of Extension on a public thread?
Please fix the delays in Opera extensions and reply on the extension admin-dev chat directly.
I have extensions with + 1 year waiting...
Just fix the delays, hire more people to do reviews and stop this circus.

Greetings.

[leocg]

leocg Moderator Volunteer @oinkandstuff last edited by

@oinkandstuff said in Very long extension moderation process:

why is Opera is making live Debug of Extension on a public thread?

Because people started doing it here?

[A Former User]

A Former User last edited by

Could you please take a look at package/239325/
The automated process didnt seem to work.
Ive waited over a week with no response, just submitted an update.. but I dont imagine it will add itself..

[oktools]

oktools @tnowak last edited by

@tnowak hello. Please post the extension. Made all the corrections indicated by the moderators. package/21805

[A Former User]

A Former User @tnowak last edited by

@tnowak, we have made all the appropriate changes and submitted the extension once again. Could you check it at your convenience?

[oktools]

oktools last edited by

Hello. Why can’t my extension be published for more than 2 months? Users complain that it does not work (see the latest comments in the reviews). Other extensions at https://addons.opera.com/en/ are updated, and new ones appear every day. My extension has over 1 million downloads, good reviews. Google Chrome and Mozilla Firefeh published a new version during the day. Why are there such delays in Opera? In the panel, the developer generally moderators do not respond.

package/21805