• Login
    • Search
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Users
    • Groups
    • Rules
    • Help

    Do more on the web, with a fast and secure browser!

    Download Opera browser with:

    • built-in ad blocker
    • battery saver
    • free VPN
    Download Opera

    please bring back show-save-file-dialog-on-risky-download

    Suggestions and feature requests
    download
    2
    8
    3335
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • my1xt
      my1xt last edited by

      back in earlier versions opera didnt annoy us all the time with asking for a save file dialog for the exe files but just asked whether to DL this file or not and just save it to the preset DL folder. and even when the save dialog was introduced there was a nifty setting to throw that thing back into oblivion where it belongs.

      opera://flags/#show-save-file-dialog-on-risky-download

      please bring back this setting It's REALLY annoying having that save file dialog.

      and it gets even worse when you include cases like this:
      https://forums.opera.com/topic/23497/download-folder-is-ignored

      Reply Quote 0
        1 Reply Last reply
      • my1xt
        my1xt last edited by

        sorry for pushing this but I have a question. is there any reason why this was removed in the first place?

        Reply Quote 0
          leocg 1 Reply Last reply
        • leocg
          leocg Moderator Volunteer @my1xt last edited by

          @my1xt Like any flag, it was an experiment. And the experimentation period has ended.

          Reply Quote 0
            1 Reply Last reply
          • my1xt
            my1xt last edited by my1xt

            but the way it works now is totally ugly, it saves the files somewhere were you last used that save dialog on instead of the folder you have preset for DLs, which is crazy. the other 2 big non-MS browsers (FF and chrome), and even IE, which had been doing this for half an eternity are doing it like that as well. they ask whether to save or not and dont pop up something that defaults to the last location where you for example saved a picture in.

            also hadnt been this even standard behavior for a long time?

            Reply Quote 0
              leocg 1 Reply Last reply
            • leocg
              leocg Moderator Volunteer @my1xt last edited by

              @my1xt Non-executable files should be saved on the folder specified on settings page if you don't have the option to ask for the download folder every time.
              Executable files will trigger the save as dialog for you to choose where to save it. In this case, last used folder will be remembered by Windows.

              Also remember that the folder you choose on settings is for when you right click on a link and select 'save link content as'.

              Reply Quote 0
                1 Reply Last reply
              • my1xt
                my1xt last edited by

                @leocg said in please bring back show-save-file-dialog-on-risky-download:

                Executable files will trigger the save as dialog for you to choose where to save it. In this case, last used folder will be remembered by Windows.

                and THIS is the problem, which wasnt there when this flag was still there (or even earlier, default)

                Reply Quote 0
                  leocg 1 Reply Last reply
                • leocg
                  leocg Moderator Volunteer @my1xt last edited by

                  @my1xt This is related to security, so I don't think they will change anything. But who knows?

                  Reply Quote 0
                    1 Reply Last reply
                  • my1xt
                    my1xt last edited by my1xt

                    so why is it more secure to have it open a save dialog in comparison to just ask download or not download

                    this is how it looks with the flag set to no but prompt on risky downloads on active

                    0_1523895686312_Screenshot (129).png

                    Reply Quote 0
                      1 Reply Last reply
                    • First post
                      Last post

                    Computer browsers

                    • Opera for Windows
                    • Opera for Mac
                    • Opera for Linux
                    • Opera beta version
                    • Opera USB

                    Mobile browsers

                    • Opera for Android
                    • Opera Mini
                    • Opera Touch
                    • Opera for basic phones

                    • Add-ons
                    • Opera account
                    • Wallpapers
                    • Opera Ads

                    • Help & support
                    • Opera blogs
                    • Opera forums
                    • Dev.Opera

                    • Security
                    • Privacy
                    • Cookies Policy
                    • EULA
                    • Terms of Service

                    • About Opera
                    • Press info
                    • Jobs
                    • Investors
                    • Become a partner
                    • Contact us

                    Follow Opera

                    • Opera - Facebook
                    • Opera - Twitter
                    • Opera - YouTube
                    • Opera - LinkedIn
                    • Opera - Instagram

                    © Opera Software 1995-