When I first heard about Opera One coming with version 100, I was excited for the changes, but after I tried out the beta, I was left scared and concerned about my future use of Opera and was apprehensive of what's coming next.
I even submitted feedback, about 3-4 months ago about all the things that changed for the worse, I will list them below, and I hoped that in a few months time, these issues will be resolved, but they are not, and it seems like Opera is even worse now.
The issues are mostly stemming from UI changes.
Here is a side-by-side comparison on the same website loaded in Opera One and Brave:
As you can see, the margins on Opera's UI are bigger, which results in less of the webpage content to be visible compared to Brave when both browser UIs are only displaying two rows of roughly the same content - tab bar, back/forward, reload, address bar, etc.
- This is the number one issue with Opera One - the UI became enlarged for no reason whatsoever. The regular tabs in Opera 99 and prior, which were modeled after folder tabs are now replaced with these "tab islands" or whatever they are called. I think first Edge or Firefox started using them, then the other copied them and finally Opera copied them.
The problem with tab islands is they take up so much useless space that can be used to reduce the overall size of the browser chrome (or UI). They have these artistic shadows underneath the selected tab to imply a sense of depth, but this is largely useless, since if the selected tab was connected to the address bar, like it used to be before, it will still be the tab that stands out the most... like it used to be and the UI will be a few pixels thinner vertically.
Here is another image of Opera's UI, this time, the context menu:
- As you can see, this is problem two - the rounded corners of the browser context menu do not correspond to the highlighted item (in purple), which on its own does not have rounded corners, so if you zoom in and look closely, the purple highlight goes out of the rounded context menu by a few pixels.
I know this is not a huge issue, but it shows that whoever works on the UI is very unprofessional and sloppy with his/her work. I'm also using Windows 10, which still doesn't have rounded corners like Windows 11, but it only makes the problem more apparent - Opera One's UI doesn't translate well between different OS versions.
- Problem #3 is that Opera One changed the UI in such a way, that made the browser very difficult to use, in my case - pretty useless. Before Opera One, we were able to drag the mouse cursor to the topmost edge of the screen and select the tabs, the Opera menu and the minimize/maximize/close buttons, this relied on a muscle memory that has been built into people for decades of using a computer - where they can drag the mouse cursor on certain parts of the edge of the screen and click to perform an action without shifting their focus to that part of the screen, but now Opera One has removed this.
Not only this, but they have added a frame around the web page content, which also makes using the scrollbar for scrolling through the page harder as I described above. Before we were able to drag the cursor to the rightmost edge of the screen where the scrollbar is and then grab it, but now it's impossible, because it results in grabbing this newly added border instead and dragging results in resizing the whole window and dragging it around the screen.
Same happens if you try to open the Opera menu or close the browser when minimized - you will drag the cursor to the top left or right corner and click, but nothing will happen.
It's strange, because they have made this works for selecting tabs, but not for the other buttons. For me this is inconsistent UX design and very unprofessional and redundant. It's as if the people who designed this UI don't use Opera or are some 18 year old interns who were born with smartphones in hand and have no experience how to use a desktop so they aren't even realizing they are ruining Opera with Opera One.
- The next problem is the reduced customization options in Opera. Not being able to edit or create a new search engine is ridiculous, because Chrome, or Chromium to be precise, which Opera uses as a base allows this, Brave allows it, Vivaldi allows it, it's only Opera who is blocking this. I want to use Startpage as my default search engine and on other Chromium browsers I can use it, only on Opera I can't unless I go through some weird hoops, which I won't bother with, I will just use another Chromium browser instead. It's actually very simple.
Opera when it was using Presto was all about customization and serving the user, now the power dynamic has shifted completely where the browser is very limited and it feels like it's the user who is supposed to serve the browser or in other words - adapt to its crap factor instead of adapting it to his/her needs.
I remember, Opera 14 and probably all the way up until Opera 20, it was limited, compared to Presto Opera, but at least the UI was good, there was more freedom to customize it.
It's hard to find old images on the internet from the Opera 14-20 days and I won't bother trying to install one to prove my point, so here are some images of it I found just for people to see and be reminded how beautiful Opera used to look and how clean and compact the UI was:
And this was after they switched to Chromium or Blink. In fact the change was so good back then, that I immediately loved Opera and thought it will become the best browser. In fact, back then and still today, Opera for some reason is really fast at loading itself and loading web page content.
But since then Opera has become more worse and bloated. The UI became worse, there were more limitations imposed, a lot of the customization options were removed. Yet somehow despite becoming a bloated browser, Opera was still lightning fast. Before version 100, or Opera One, I was still considering using it as my main browser despite not being able to set Startpage as my default engine, but when Opera One released and now a few more versions followed and the problems with the horrible UI/UX are still present, I am 100% certain I can't use Opera anymore or recommend it to my friends or install it and set it up on their computers, because it's not good anymore.
I'm not even going to touch upon that AI crap that's also another useless bloat to the browser, just like the useless existence of Opera GX and the Opera Web3 alternatives, it looks like a desperate attempt from Opera to stay relevant, which reminds me of that Steve Buscemi picture where a tone-deaf old fart is trying to pass off as a teen and fails to realize how much of a failed attempt it was:
So these are my grievances with Opera One. I've been using Opera since around 2006-2007, less so before 2013 when it dropped Presto for WebKit/Blink, but I still have used it a lot and comparing what it used to be then to what it is now is night and day difference... for the worse.
That's it, whoever read this far, thanks for taking the time reading my rant, I certainly took my time and enjoyed talking about the things I like and dislike about Opera. I do wish the people calling the shots in Opera read this and hopefully some of them weren't born after the year 2001 so they can understand the problems with the current state of Opera One and consider doing something about it, even reverting to the version 99 UI will probably fix 90% of these problems, but somehow I doubt this will happen. The most likely scenario will be my thread will be locked or deleted, because this will be viewed as something bad and someone's feelings will get hurt from it. In the best case scenario, it will just be ignored and another unheard voice in the vast desert added to the list.
Have a good one!