@Pouriya-Jamshidi Yeah I figured it was something YouTube did intentionally (or not) that broke the extension. In case this is helpful at all, when I first started coming across the return of the button it wasn't as frequent as it is now. And it'll only do it if I'm watching multiple videos in a row, versus say when I'm only watching one video that's an hour long or more. I wanna say it was January when it first started happening, with the frequency increasing by early March.
This isn't the first time I've had an app (on PC and on mobile) that improved something about YouTube break because YouTube either caught on about it and deliberately updated something just to break the app or it was just a general update to the site that just randomly happened to break the extension or app. I appreciate that you're going to look into it.